Are Deepfakes Legal? AI Likeness Laws and Fair Use

Documentary First, Episode 290 · with Anne B. Easton, entertainment attorney · 42 minutes · November 19, 2026

Listen: Apple Podcasts, Spotify and all apps · Watch: YouTube · Read: Full transcript

Can someone copy your face and your voice, put them in a film and never ask you?

Deepfakes and AI likeness laws are moving fast, and whether a deepfake is legal depends on where you are. In the United States, entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton explains, the question is whether the person gave permission to use their face and voice. In Europe, the question is whether the audience knows it is looking at AI. For documentaries, fair use and archival footage raise a version of the same problem: when can you use something you didn't make?

In Episode 290, Christian sits down with Anne B. Easton, an entertainment attorney with Blakemore Law and Entertainment Law Partners, for the first of a two-part conversation. Anne, back on Documentary First after Episodes 248 and 250, joins from Paris after the International Association of Entertainment Lawyers' legal summit at the Amsterdam Dance Event. She follows up on the Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni case and explains why, in her reading, Lively's harassment claims never reached a jury: the judge found she was an independent contractor, not an employee.

Anne walks through the AI copies of the "Storm" music video by GENER8ION and Yung Lean, moral rights in France, US publicity rights and the NO FAKES Act, AI disclosure labels in Europe, and Denmark's bill to let people control their own face. Christian brings in Phil Maher from Episode 287 on telling audiences when footage is AI created, and James L. Freedman from Episode 288 on fair use as a gray area. Then Anne breaks down the four factors of fair use, why a $125 license can cost less than a lawsuit, and how the court in the Tiger King case changed its mind about a funeral video Netflix used in the series.

In this episode, you'll learn

  • How US publicity rights and the proposed NO FAKES Act treat your face and voice
  • What moral rights are, and why Anne says they can't be waived in France
  • Why Anne thinks Denmark's push to let people control their own face is where the world is headed
  • Why Christian and Anne both want documentaries to be upfront about AI
  • Why a $125 license can cost less than the risk of a lawsuit
  • How the Tiger King ruling treated a clip used as historical evidence
  • Anne's advice: go to the conferences and the film festivals

Questions and answers

Are deepfakes legal?

It depends on where you are. Entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton explains that US law treats an AI copy of a person mainly through publicity rights: did the person give permission to use their face or voice? In Europe, she says, the focus is on the audience and whether people know the material was created with AI. The law is still catching up, with the proposed NO FAKES Act in the United States and a Danish bill on deepfakes.

Do documentaries need to label AI reenactments?

In France, yes, according to entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton. She says European rules focus on disclosure, so a film with an AI reenactment that plays in France needs a label telling viewers what is AI. In her view, AI-created images and voices must be disclosed; AI used to polish a script probably needn't be. Phil Maher says filmmakers should tell the audience when footage is AI created, and Christian Taylor agrees, saying it builds the audience's trust.

What are the four factors of fair use?

Courts weigh four factors: the purpose of the use, the nature of the original work, how much of it is taken, and the harm to the original work's market. Entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton says no single factor decides a case, so no clip length is automatically safe. She tells clients they can take the risk on a short clip, but a $125 license can cost far less than a lawsuit, attorneys' fees and court fees.

What happened in the Tiger King fair use case?

Netflix used about a minute of Timothy Sepi's funeral video in Tiger King. A Tenth Circuit panel first found the use wasn't fair because it commented on Joe Exotic rather than on the video itself. On rehearing in 2026, the court reversed course and found fair use. Anne B. Easton reads the ruling as accepting that footage used as historical evidence can serve a new purpose. The court also said documentaries get no automatic presumption of fair use.

Why were Blake Lively's harassment claims dismissed?

In April 2026, Judge Lewis J. Liman found that Blake Lively was an independent contractor on It Ends With Us rather than an employee, so she couldn't bring sexual harassment claims under federal workplace law. Entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton says that is why the claims never reached a jury, not a finding that there was no harassment. Justin Baldoni's $400 million countersuit was dismissed in 2025, and the case settled before trial in May 2026 (court reporting by CBS News, AP and the ABA Journal).

Chapters

  • 0:00 Lively v. Baldoni Explained
  • 6:55 Inside a Legal Summit
  • 10:08 Are Deepfakes Legal?
  • 14:30 Publicity Rights and NO FAKES
  • 16:42 Should Documentaries Disclose Reenactments?
  • 20:42 Europe's Labels and Denmark's Bill
  • 25:55 Four Factors of Fair Use
  • 29:34 The Tiger King Ruling
  • 33:16 DocuView Deja View Pick
  • 36:52 Blackmail, Shutdowns and Claude

DocuView Deja View pick

Anne's pick is The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist (2026), directed by Daniel Roher and Charlie Tyrell. Roher, who won the Oscar for Navalny, asks AI founders and researchers, Sam Altman among them, whether we should bring children into a world shaped by AI. It is streaming on Netflix and Peacock in the US, and every guest pick is on the DocuView Deja View page.

About the guest

Anne B. Easton
Entertainment attorney, Blakemore Law; Of Counsel, Entertainment Law Partners

Anne B. Easton is an entertainment attorney based in Los Angeles and Paris. She advises on film and television development, production, distribution, financing and intellectual property, and serves as outside general counsel to emerging companies. She left Sheppard Mullin and founded Blakemore Law in 2025, and she co-hosts My Lawyer Friend Podcast.

Blakemore Law · Entertainment Law Partners

My Lawyer Friend Podcast

Anne's own podcast breaks down legal and lifestyle topics "with your friend (if your friend was also a lawyer)."

Website · Apple Podcasts · Instagram

About Documentary First

For people who make documentaries and people who love them. Discover how documentaries actually get made, paid for and seen with filmmaker Christian Taylor. Plus DocuView Deja View, where every guest recommends a documentary worth watching. One week, a long-form conversation about a guest's journey, projects and lessons; the next, The Deep Dive, Christian's short solo reflection on one idea from that conversation. Guests have included Ken Burns and PBS American Masters creator Susan Lacy. Christian directed the award-winning documentary The Girl Who Wore Freedom. Nearly 300 conversations. Listen Notes top 3% worldwide. 4.8 on Apple Podcasts. New episodes every week.

Listen and subscribe wherever you get podcasts · Watch on YouTube · About the podcast · Join the Documentary First community on Patreon · All platforms · Christian Taylor on LinkedIn

Resources mentioned

This episode is brought to you by Virgil Films Entertainment, distributor of Super Size Me and the Oscar-nominated Restrepo, with over 25 years of distribution experience.

Full transcript

Lively v. Baldoni Explained

Anne B. Easton: You are looking down the barrel of a lawsuit and attorneys' fees and court fees when you could have just paid a $125 license.

Christian Taylor: Can someone make a copy of your face and your voice and put it in a film and never ask you? Well, in some countries, that answer is about to change. And if you've ever borrowed a few seconds of someone else's footage for your film, you'll want to hear what a court decided this year. Our esteemed guest today is Anne B. Easton of Blakemore Law in partnership with Entertainment Law Partners. And she's just come from an entertainment law summit in Amsterdam. Welcome to Documentary First. I'm your host and a documentary filmmaker myself, Christian Taylor. Anne, welcome back to Documentary First. I'm really glad you're here.

Anne: Thank you so much. I'm happy to be back.

Christian: All right, before we dig in, I wanna come back to the last time you were on the show, you were here talking about this case between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni. And that has since become settled law, I think. And it turned out a little differently than we thought. So can you catch us up with that?

Anne: First of all, thanks for having me back. I'm glad to be here with you and to discuss some new topics and to be sitting in Europe while I talk about it.

Christian: Yeah, I'm so sorry. Catch me up. Your life has changed a little bit. Let's do that first.

Anne: Yes, since we last spoke, I was I think I was still at Sheppard Mullin. I was still at the law firm. I've since left Big Law and I was part of the California wildfires that happened last year in January and I was evacuated and moved quickly and left the law firm, moved and ended a relationship all at the same time. So I was like, that's the a good reason to leave and pick up and go. So I lived in Montana for a little while and then and then I was back in LA and I started my own podcast and started my own law firm, Blakemore Law. And then I partnered with my first boss in the industry who started his own law firm as well. And we've been working on some really incredible films recently. And his firm is Entertainment Law Partners.

Christian: Yeah, I've walked with you through some of this and I've just watched your incredible resilience and endurance. You have also gone through some incredible challenges personally, but what I have been amazed by is just your incredible will to push on, your positivity and also your ability to work while all of that has been happening and reinvent things. Your podcast is really amazing. I would love people to check that out. Called My Lawyer Friend Podcast. And you can talk about that a little bit at the end of the show because I do want people to hear that. Yeah, so I congratulate you. Right now you're in Paris, actually it's nighttime there.

Anne: I am.

Christian: So thank you for working at the end of your day.

Anne: Yes, yes, of course. It's October, so it's getting darker faster here. But yeah, I kind of could live anywhere when you have your own business. I decided to live here. I have family here and it was the only city that really stuck with me. So here I am. And we'll see how long it lasts.

Christian: Well, it puts you in a great position to help a lot of different people. You're still working in big entertainment. So I congratulate you for that. All right. So let's get back to this case. Talk to me about where we are now.

Anne: I had talked to you guys about Blake Lively and that I thought that she had had a strong case against Justin Baldoni. And based on what I had read in the case files at the time, I still stand by that assessment. But since then, the case has obviously ended, and how it ended is sort of worth understanding, I think, for people, because a lot of people now are looking at it like, Blake Lively was wrong. There was no harassment. There was no issue. And that's actually not what happened based on my reading of what actually happened in the case. So Justin Baldoni countersued for $400 million against Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds. And that case was dismissed in June, I think, of 2025. So like almost immediately. And then the court held that the statements in her harassment complaint were privileged and could not support a defamation claim. So that was one of the biggest reasons why those complaints got dismissed. Not because there wasn't harassment, but because they were privileged and couldn't go into the defamation claim. So But what deserves more attention is why her sexual harassment claims never actually reached the jury. And it wasn't because the court found her allegations didn't have any merit. It actually was because the judge essentially concluded that she was an independent contractor rather than an employee, which places her outside of federal protections for workplace harassment law. And that is a huge deal, in my opinion, because that means that big actors and even small actors that are on these film sets are going to be deemed all as independent contractors. And that's how it works in general. Films are absolutely magic. They are huge companies that set up for 18 months and then they wind down completely. They hire hundreds and thousands of people, and then they wind down. And within that, everyone is operating like a temporary employee. But all of these actors and even, crew members and heads of department, they all come in as an independent contractor who's being hired with through their LLC usually, or their S-corp or whatever corporation they're using in order to be hired. And they do that for their own tax benefits, essentially. But because of those protections, you don't get protected by federal workplace harassment law, which is a crazy thing that happened. So I think that lots of people, and maybe some people do understand this, but within the employment context, she basically couldn't bring her harassment claims simply because she wasn't an employee. And it wasn't because there wasn't sexual harassment. So I was correct in my assessment, I think, of the actual case.

Christian: Well, more than proving that you were right, which isn't for which is important.

Anne: Which is it's not the point, but yeah, yeah.

Christian: Which is important, but it just feels very unjust.

Anne: Yes. And sometimes that's how it works, but like it does. It feels unjust, right? And it then it you realize, okay, well then how do we change this for people in the future? I mean, because this is Blake Lively who has a huge backing and she has plenty of, resources. And what about the women who don't have these resources and who don't have the protections of the federal workplace harassment laws. And so I think cases like this have to happen in order for our legislators to change the rules.

Inside a Legal Summit

Christian: Agreed. All right, let's move on. You have been in Amsterdam. So talk to me about what took you there.

Anne: Now that I'm living in Europe, it was recommended to me that join some associations here. And one of them that was recommended to me while I was at Cannes at the film festival in May, was to join the International Association of Entertainment Lawyers. And I had been speaking with an attorney at this law firm called Fidal Avocats here, and she was very friendly. But I was really very confused about what this event was because they said, okay, there's this legal summit that's happening in Amsterdam next month. It's our like yearly summit. We've been doing it for the last, 50 years. They're celebrating their 50th year this year. And they tell me that it's at this thing called the Amsterdam Dance Event. And I looked it up and I'm like, is this a rave? Is this like is this just a bunch of DJs like from all over the world coming to like debut their music? Like, what is this? So I asked a bunch of questions. No one responded to my questions. I'm like, I guess I'm gonna pay for this and go and see if it's worth it. And sometimes you have to make those decisions, I think. And I am so glad I took the risk because it was absolutely incredible. I love being around creative people and musicians who are also trying to understand the business of their creations, essentially. And and that's what we offered to them as the legal professionals there. And we had a bunch of panels where we taught about, AI and whether or not you can use AI replicas in the form of, someone's face or their voice. And then we used it also like what DJs can use in terms of other people's music. It's more difficult, by the way, to use anything AI related with in terms of music. I also learned so much because they do this incredible thing where it's like the legal update, where they talk about every single copyright and trademark issue, the biggest ones in Europe and in the US. And then we also had Hong Kong and I like other places in Asia. Gosh, they didn't touch on Russia. We talked about Latin America and a little bit about Canada, but Canada is very similar to us in terms of a few different things. But it was very illuminating about international entertainment law. And it was very rewarding for me specifically because I gained so many opportunities there. I they produce a book every year about legal issues that our clients are facing and they asked me to contribute to it this year. So I'll get to be in a book this year.

Christian: Congratulations.

Anne: I highly recommend anybody in any field go to conferences, go to film festivals, go to the things because you're not gonna get connected and you're not gonna move your life forward if you're just sitting at home looking and scrolling on your phone. I can promise you that.

Christian: Great words of advice. All right.

Anne: Yeah.

Are Deepfakes Legal?

Christian: Now you had mentioned to me something about AI doppelgangers. Now I didn't even know what that term was. Fill me in on that.

Anne: So AI doppelganger gangers are exactly what you would think they are. Our, doppelgangers, we say we have celebrity doppelgangers, right? So who's your a or celebrity doppelganger first?

Christian: Hm, good question. I don't know.

Anne: No, you haven't no one's told you look like somebody?

Christian: Well, a long time ago, there was a girl in Fried Green Tomatoes.

Anne: My doppelgangers that I've been told that I look like, and I'm not sure if I look like them right now, but one of them is Evan Rachel Wood. And I think I look I look like her in that one TV show that's like a Western show on HBO is very intense. And then The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. What's her name? Rachel Brosnahan. Yeah. So those are my doppelgangers. Anyway, so the AI doppelgangers, essentially they're realistic AI replicas of a person's real face, what you would think, or their voice and their movements and they can be made to say or do things that obviously you never did. And the US treats these, they call them deep fakes essentially, but the EU test actually is based on resemblism and realism. And it's not actually based on the tool that's used, which is a little bit different in the US, but a good example that I saw recently was with this Swedish rapper. His name's like Yung Lean, and I hope that I'm pronouncing it correctly. But he has this super cool music video called Storm, where it's choreographed really interestingly, like the dancers like move their heads up and down and they go all around him, but he is remaining in the frame completely still as everyone's dancing around him. And what happened recently, I think it was either ChatGPT or like OpenAI. Somebody said, AI is so good, we can recreate this and it's fair use and it's there's no issue because it's commentary, and we're it's derivative, whatever. And it's not I disagree with this, what people are saying, by the way. Let me make this statement. But they're saying we can recreate this and AI is just as good. And they recreated it and showed that it could be done. But to me, it looked different because it was actually well, not it looked different. They recreated it with some of the most famous people and faces from 2026. And one of them was the Norwegian footballer who everybody sort of knew because he was so good. His name's Erling Haaland. And then several other characters, but obviously one of the biggest things was the people moving around, the choreographed dance. And when I saw that, I was like, I'm pretty sure this is infringement. But that's those are the types of arguments that are coming out right now. It's happening so fast, the law has to catch up, basically. So I saw this and it was on Instagram and it was a post that was from New York magazine. And they said that this essentially was a glimpse of the future in which people can lift an artist's style or even their entire personality as easily as once was downloading an MP3 song, essentially. I think it's fascinating but also depressing, basically, is what Gavras said, which is the Swedish rapper.

Christian: And so what did you say? Like what's your response?

Anne: My response was I think that this is textbook copyright infringement and probably a violation of his of other European rights that he cannot waive, which are called moral rights essentially, and they're usually waived in the US and in those contracts, but in France, where I mean he's a Swedish rapper, but I think he's also French. Is he French?

Christian: Well even so he's in the EU and so.

Anne: He lives, yeah, he lives in France, I'm pretty sure. So in France, the author's right to object to use of their moral rights can't be sold or like they can't even be waived. And that's been the case for, as long as I've been studying in intellectual property.

Christian: Well, this sounds like it's going to be a big fight for the future, and it does sound like there's a difference between the laws in Europe

Anne: Mm-hmm.

Christian: on these things and the laws in the US.

Publicity Rights and NO FAKES

Anne: Yes, yes. So the difference I think within the US versus the EU is that in the US they're basing everything with regard to AI and doppelgangers on publicity rights. And our publicity rights are like our likeness rights. I own my face, essentially. And the release that you had me sign today, I am giving you my likeness rights to publicize and to exploit this podcast with my face on it. And I waived those rights essentially, or I gave them to you just for the specific purpose of this podcast. And then potentially for clips and everything. But if you use this for something else, you have to come and ask me for those rights to do that. And that's how the argument is basically based around in the US. And that's what the NO FAKES Act is about. It's a federal right. It has a documentary exclusion, actually, if I recall correctly. But these rules are still being made because as we all know, and when we talk about this later in the episode AI is rapidly changing and the law is gonna have to catch up. And I think that we know enough right now in order to change the legislation and have our legislators change the rules and the laws and the statutes, there will be infringement in the meantime and people will have to sue and it'll be a big mess. And something that was discussed at the legal summit that I went to in Amsterdam was that the same kind of thing happened when the internet came out, 20 plus years ago. There was a bunch of litigation about people's copyrights and trademarks being put on the internet because they weren't getting proper credit and they weren't getting residuals, they weren't making money off of those things. And people were copying it and putting it on the internet. And the courts had to try to formulate a way to protect the owners of those copyrights, of those creative works. And that's the same thing that's happening now with AI, but AI has the potential to be a much stronger, scarier beast, I think, than the internet alone. Yeah.

Should Documentaries Disclose Reenactments?

Christian: Fascinating. Now, to repeat, the NO FAKES Act would create a federal right over your voice and likeness. It does exclude documentaries. I do wonder if that's a free pass for filmmakers. However, I have someone in this industry that I spoke with a couple of weeks ago or a few weeks ago named Phil Maher. He has a particular point of view on this.

Phil Maher: I think if you're going to make AI content to recreate some historical battle or whatever you want to do, you've really got to tell the audience that this is AI created. This is a fictional rendition of what may or may not have happened at that time.

Christian: So that's Phil Maher, and that's his point of view. And I happen to agree with him that in order to gain the trust of our audience, we really do need to be upfront with them, even in documentaries, in terms of when we're using AI and when we're not. I think it's the integrous thing to do. What is your point of view?

Anne: I absolutely agree with you. Part of my overarching position on AI is an ethical one. And it's coming from an ethical place. And I was gonna talk about this when I talked about my documentary that I wanna recommend to your listeners, but I wrote an article when I was in Big Law a few years ago about this in 2024. And actually, I'm pretty sure that Dario Amodei wrote something as well in 2024 around this time, which was essentially what I wrote in my article. But one of my colleagues wrote the portion about how AI worked, about the outputs and the inputs. Cause at that time in 2024, no one really understood how it worked. And what it meant and what it meant for copyright holders, and about making new things with AI and whether or not it could be copyrighted. But I also said in this article that I was a little bit critical of some of these AI companies, and I said, I don't think that they are seeing the inherent risk in what making the AI machines stronger could do. And not just from they're gonna, take over the human race position. It's we are going to take away the ability for people to make a salary and to have money in order to like feed their families. And we have a moral duty in order to make sure that that does not happen, that these computers do not take over and take over especially creative endeavors, in my opinion. And the only things I was saying that AI should be doing is administrative tasks and research and things that we really don't like doing. And it's like, yes, let's have them do like terrible jobs that we don't want to do, like my laundry. Like, I don't want to do my laundry. But but I also said that the balance there was that we need the leaders in AI, the companies, the founders of these places, to work together with the legislators. And they need to also, the legislators also need to make rules that will that will protect the people and also rein in these companies. And that is exactly what Dario Amodei said in his article. My article never went out because we represented too many AI-based companies, and it was critical of those companies. And as an attorney at a large law firm, I we couldn't release an article about that. And then, the article mysteriously left my computer. I don't know what happened to it. So yeah. Why not?

Christian: Interesting. Well, Dario Amodei is the head of Anthropic who owns Claude. For those of you who aren't tracking that, don't know how you can be, but I do wish people would have listened to you or you wish that article would have gone out because clearly those recommendations are not quite being followed very well, even though everyone's trumpeting the same exact thing now, it seems.

Anne: Okay.

Europe's Labels and Denmark's Bill

Christian: But we're having trouble figuring this whole thing out for sure. Now next question I have for you is if a film with an AI reenactment, and this, does apply to me, plays in France, does it need a label on screen?

Anne: Yes, yes, it does. If and that is the difference actually between the NO FAKES Act in the United States versus the EU. And the EU is focusing more on the disclosure that it's AI than on creating the replica in general, essentially. So so that's where my argument of about the Swedish rapper and that Storm video. It makes sense in the US, but it doesn't necessarily make sense in Europe. So that that is required. And every single time if I post something from my podcast on social media here, I have to select a little, I have to toggle something that says if I created it with AI. And I'm also trying to understand, like, okay, so I'm not creating anything with AI. Like I'm creating these scripts, I'm creating, but like I use AI to like fine-tune them. Do I then have to disclose that part? Or I don't think that you do. What you do have to disclose is if the image and the voice and all of those things are being created with AI. So that it's understand that it's what you're looking at is not real. I mean, it's real in the sense that it's in an intangible thing that we can look at, but it's not wasn't created specifically by a human. Maybe they gave the inputs. But see, this is the biggest thing is that you can argue so many different sides. Even when I start talking about it, I almost talk myself out of my own opinion. But that's like a lawyer thing that happens. So.

Christian: Well, we are always asked on YouTube and on several other places to check that same box. Is this created with AI or not? Which I'm thankful for. Now, next question. Denmark wants people to control their own face almost like a copyright. Is that where the rest of the world is headed?

Anne: Yes, I think that it is. And I think that that's a good place to start. And it's a good way to protect our ability to make money. Like our faces are a tangible right, basically. And I would not want somebody to use my face, and that's part of it. It's that you have a podcast where you're putting your face onto platforms every day. You would not want your face to be used to sell a product that maybe you didn't ever agree to sell. And I mean, actually talked about this on my podcast the other day and then on like some content where I said somebody has used your content or your voice or your face, you can tell the platform essentially that there's been a privacy violation and that they've taken your face and your likeness rights essentially but also if they like a marketing person or an advertisement has used your face or your voice or something for a sexually explicit ad or even an ad like for firearms or something that or like drugs or that you wouldn't agree to that's like a separate violation and I think that that's where the rules are going and I think that that's very good that this is where it's moving towards.

Christian: Good. I hope so too. Now we're gonna take a quick break. When we come back, I wanna talk with you about the footage that so many of us built our films from.

Virgil Films (sponsor): Today's episode is brought to you by our friends over at Virgil Films. With over 25 years of distribution experience, Virgil has released such hits as Super Size Me and the Oscar-nominated Restrepo, along with a trove of indie treasures like Forks Over Knives, To Die For, Seven Yards, and Speed Is Expensive. Now you can find all of those films, along with the entire Virgil catalog, on any transactional platform out there like Amazon, Apple TV, YouTube, Tubi, and the rest. Are you a filmmaker having trouble with distribution? Talk to Virgil. They work with every major platform directly, and they offer a variety of deals that fit every filmmaker's needs, from standard distribution to service deals. They do it all. And they don't just distribute films, they elevate them. Truthfully, they're just really good people to work with. So if you want to learn more, head over to Virgilfilms.com and tell them Christian Taylor sent you. And now, on with the show.

Christian: And we're back with Anne Easton. All right, and during the break, you told me something I think you need to follow up with the last question.

Anne: Right. So I think that the point that we should land on of the difference between between the US and the EU is how courts are going to look at a decision. So in the US, they're going to ask whether or not the person who's created the AI replica, if they had the permission of that person whose voice or face they've used to create the AI replica. Whereas in Europe, they're focused more on the audience and whether or not the audience is aware of the fact that the material is AI content or created by AI.

Four Factors of Fair Use

Christian: Okay. Makes sense. A couple weeks ago, documentary filmmaker James Freedman sat in this chair and told me how he thinks about fair use. Take a listen.

James L. Freedman: Well, it's not a black and white thing. It's a gray area, but what I do to try and make it a little darker gray. Fair use has to illuminate what you're saying.

Christian: All right, and a gray area he tries to make a little bit darker gray.

Anne: I guess I'll explain fair use in general. There's four factors that you have to look at or that courts look at when they are thinking about archival footage and fair use. And those factors are the purpose of the use, the nature of the work, how much of it is taken, which is that, idea of you can take 10 seconds and it's not all and then it's not as infringing. And the final factor is the harm to the original copyrighted material, that market, essentially. And no single one of these factors will decide whether or not it's infringement or whether or not it's fair use. So no length basically is safe and I think that different attorneys are more conservative. I tend to be a little bit more risk tolerant. However, I'm representing people who own copyrights. And I want to be very cognizant of that if I ever use some sort of a clip. So I did something the other day where I made a little video of what it feels like for an attorney, in Big Law, and you tell a client like at 3 p.m. on a Friday, I'm not available for the rest of the weekend, which is audacious, it would feel for a lawyer. And I used a clip from the trailer of King Arthur to show what it feels like when you do that. It's like pulling the sword out of the stone and then falling over, basically. And then I used the music from it essentially, but then I had my own video behind the trailer. And I ultimately chose not to post it because I felt that it was potentially infringing. And even though I nothing probably would have happened because it wasn't really being used for commercial use. Everything I do arguably could be commercial use because I'm I have a law firm and I'm using my platform in order to market my law firm and to bring in more clients. And I get consultations through the podcast. But there's nothing that could happen. And I would tell a client this. Would say, you can take the risk and use the 10-second clip. And probably nothing will happen, but it's possible that someone may come to you and say, You are infringing on my copyright. You should have paid a license in order to use it. This isn't fair use, and then you are looking down the barrel of a lawsuit and attorneys' fees and court fees when you could have just paid, a $125 license. So all of life is a risk assessment in general. And I have had to become more risk tolerant in my position. And I know a lot of attorneys who are far more conservative than I am, but those more conservative attorneys are in different positions and they feel safe in those positions. I have taken a lot more risks in my life in general. And I think you need both types of attorneys in general.

Christian: Very wise. Now

Anne: Yeah.

The Tiger King Ruling

Christian: there was a case recently in the Tiger King situation. I don't know if people remember the Tiger King series on Netflix. They kind of got in a little trouble. Why don't you tell us a little bit about that case and then we're gonna talk about how the court in the Tiger King case changed its mind. And so I'd like

Anne: Yeah.

Christian: you to tell us about the case and then why they changed its mind.

Anne: So Netflix used a 60 plus second footage essentially of a 24-minute funeral video that had been recorded by Timothy Sepi and in one of those episodes in the Tiger King series. They cut it against some commentary of Joe Exotic's late husband's mother. The use was only 2.6% of the episode and then even less of the entire series. But the court actually found that because it commented on Joe Exotic, it wasn't commenting on the funeral video. They actually found that the use wasn't transformative. But then on the rehearing, after like a supplemental briefing on documentaries and on the Warhol case, had been submitted by Netflix, it found that all four factors of fair use actually favored Netflix's use of it. And we had already discussed those four factors. And the court essentially changed its mind because it accepted that using the clip was actually historical evidence, which is something that you do as a documentarian, and to show what happened and let others, react to that footage and itself was a new purpose, basically. Yeah. So it doesn't need to be a critique of the clip in order for it to be transformative. Which I found really interesting.

Christian: It is fascinating. Now the court also said documentaries get no automatic presumption of fair use. So what should a filmmaker take away from a win by a company the size of Netflix?

Anne: It's actually like a positive for filmmakers, in my opinion. I mean, it's a positive in some ways and then not in others. I mean, it means that someone who created the footage, like this Timothy Sepi guy, he created that footage and it was seen as fair use because it was a different, it was transformative enough. What Netflix did to create something new. And I think that that's it's actually allowing for more creation, more ability for creators to expand what they can create. And some people may disagree, especially the people who are the owners of the archives, I don't know. This is a big argument as well. It's there's nothing really new under the sun, and it's hard to not be copying something from somebody. We as humans also get our ideas from things that we see. I can come up with an idea, but I know how to write it because of the way that someone else wrote. I mean, I started writing essays this year and last year as a way to cope with some of the hard things that have happened in the last year. And one of my favorite authors is Joan Didion, and I realized I was writing like her and I needed to stop because I needed to write more like me. But I think that that is so common. I feel like it's positive to be able to find a balance between taking somebody's copyrighted material and seeing it as fair use and allowing there to be the free use of ideas and to make something new and creative.

DocuView Deja View Pick

Christian: There's a very fine line, no question about that. All right. Well, now we have come to everybody's favorite segment, DocuView Deja View. So before we stop today, Anne, I know that you've brought us some of your favorite documentaries. So start with this AI doc you've told us about.

Anne: Yes. Okay, I am so excited to talk about my films. So the first one that I think I will give is one that I watched recently because it's such a big topic. And it was it was directed by Daniel Roher, but it's called The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist. It was incredible. The guy did such a good job. He won the Oscar for the film Navalny. I never saw it, but it's also made by Charlie Tyrell, who produced in part the film Everything Everywhere All at Once, which is a great film. But something that Roher asks of all of the people who come on the film is because he is a father to be, is whether or not we should be bringing children into a world that is ruled by AI right now. And think it was really interesting the way that everybody answered it. Sam Altman was actually interviewed for this film and he said that he was also expecting at the time. But this film was so incredible because it touched on so many different things that we are dealing with every single day. One of the things that it said was that by the time the film comes out, it will be old news. Everything in it will be old news because it that's how fast AI is moving. And part of what I said earlier in this segment or in this in this episode was about the fact that we need to use our best judgment when we deal with AI, specifically with AI and what it can do and how powerful it can be. And we need to be our most mature selves when we're dealing with it, basically. And what the founders are arguing is that they all have better intentions than the next guy. And that they get to make the decisions because they have better intentions than somebody else. And that's also the idea that we don't want. And but this was the idea when we wanted to land on the moon and with the Cuban Missile Crisis and all these things, it was that we don't want the Soviet Union to get on the moon first because then, it'll be mass destruction for the rest of the like the world. And it's the same argument now, but now it's Putin. And we don't want Putin to have AI and have the person who basically makes all of the rules and has to job as AI.

Christian: Well, it's China too. I mean, let's be real.

Anne: And yeah, it's Putin and China. Exactly. It's also China. And they have a lot of data centers and a lot of stuff is coming through there. But their arguments it was almost dystopian. And I really, really highly recommend seeing this film.

Christian: But that that sounds it's almost dystopian. I want you to feel very depressed. So I recommend you watching this film.

Blackmail, Shutdowns and Claude

Anne: I'm serious. Because but also what was interesting is that we can still be optimistic about it because a lot of the founders are saying we don't have to be that afraid because we've now created a superhuman research machine, we as humans can be superhuman. But then the other side of the argument is the coders and the people who are really down in the trenches and dealing with all of this, and they're seeing what AI can do and how quickly it can do it, and that it's choosing autonomy in certain ways. A really good example was this one story of this coder who worked at a who was researching AI. He said that they gave ChatGPT, its strongest model, a list of tasks to complete. And during the tasks, at one point, it found out that, through some code that it was going to be shut down. And it rewrote the code so that it could finish the tasks. That was one thing. That's like a small thing. The other one was they used AI at Anthropic in order to look through everybody's emails. And as sort of like a training method and to like find it was like a safety structure, I guess. But so AI was reviewing everybody's emails, and in that process of reading these emails, an engineer had written an email saying that they were that this AI model was going to be replaced. And the AI model essentially blackmailed the engineer that was that was talking about replacing him and blackmailed him because it found out from reading his emails that he was having an affair and blackmailed him, blackmailed him by saying, I'm going to tell your wife that you're having an affair if you shut me down

Christian: My word.

Anne: Yeah. And that's the kind of stuff that it can do. That kind of stuff is very scary. And that's what I'm talking about when I say we need to legislate this. It's clearly strong enough. And there has to be a way around it. And I'm so what I did after I watched this film because I use Claude every day. Claude is my legal assistant, essentially. And my legal assistant that I have to watch very carefully and I have to review everything very carefully. But I asked Claude this question, it was almost scary to ask it, but I was like, Claude, I'm watching this movie right now and it's making me very nervous about your capabilities. And I want you to tell me and be very honest with me what you think of me and what you think of my ideas and how I work, and whether or not I have potential to actually succeed in doing the endeavors that I'm working on. And tell me where you think I can improve and whether or not I should be afraid that you as a system will take over and find a way to murder the human race. Yeah. And it actually came back to me and said, I don't have the capability to do that. I'm not going to do that. But I don't know what other people or other systems can do. And then it gave me all of these things about me in general. And it said that, which I really liked. It said that I take criticism well. And when I'm wrong about something, I take responsibility and I say, okay, okay, I'm wrong about this. Let's redirect. And I shift very quickly. And it said that not a lot of people do that, which maybe was just pandering to again. I did say not to pander to me, but. But these are the funny it's interesting that these are questions that we're asking, but it said that we shouldn't be worrying about the human rights, but we should be telling our legislators in order to legislate this. But he also has he, Claude, it has an incentive to, manipulate me, to lie and manipulate me.

Christian: Lie to lie and manipulate.

Anne: Yeah.

Christian: Yeah. It just no, I'm not going to kill you is the same thing somebody would say if they're going to kill you. So I don't know.

Anne: I know, I know.

Christian: Anyway, all right. If this helped any of you, please leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It's the best way for other filmmakers to find the show. Listen to Anne on My Lawyer Friend Podcast. We're going to put everything in the show notes below and anything that she's referenced, it's going to be there. So please find that and come back because she's going to come back for part two. We have a lot more to talk about. Everything that she shares is going to be in a lesson guide that we're going to put together. So we've got this lesson guide at documentaryfirst.com. And her DocuView Deja View recommendation is going to be on our DocuView Deja View page. So you go to our website and it says need a doc for date night. You click on that red button and it'll take you there and you'll be able to find her recommendation along with a lot of other people's as well. So Anne, it's really been a pleasure, having you here next time when we pick up. We're gonna talk about when the archive says no, and when you can't find who owns the footage, what are we gonna do? And what happens when AI meets the real thing? So that's gonna be a lot of fun.

Anne: Right. I think so too. Well, thank you so much. Can't wait to come back.

Christian: Yeah, me too. All right, everybody, thank you for listening to Documentary First, where we believe everybody has a story to tell and you can be the one to tell it. Bye, everybody.

Back to blog